← All issues

My manager told me to "keep doing what you're doing"

UNEDITD · November 2, 2026 · Maddy Viswanath
UNEDITD Presents
TOP PERSPECTIVES
EDITION 19 · WEEK OF NOVEMBER 2, 2026
MADDY VISWANATH · CRAFT YOUR CONFIDENCE
My manager told me to "keep doing what you're doing"
Let me start with a story from my years in corporate HR.
We had a great performer who had always gotten a four on their review. Then there was a new manager transition. The new manager came up through the ranks and wasn't giving effective feedback. Three months later, we lost that top performer to a competitor.
Employees don't leave managers, and employees don't leave companies. They leave when they don't see a path to growth in the company. There are still a lot of people who are just happy with the paycheck and continue doing what they do. But if we are looking to nourish our top performers, feedback is the number one reason to retain top talent.
I have been on the receiving end of this too. My own manager once told me, "Keep doing what you're doing." That was the feedback, and it was followed by a layoff. In my experience, when there is a lack of feedback, it is because the manager is not invested.
It's annual review season, so this week I want to walk you through what that season looks like from inside HR, where I think AI belongs in it, and one thing you can do before your reviews are due.
One story
For years, the last two months of the year filled my calendar with tracking the completion of reviews. It was a four-stage process. Employees wrote their self-assessment. The manager reviewed it and added a rating. It went back to the employee to acknowledge that the discussion had happened. Then the ratings were pulled into an Excel sheet, where I gathered the data to build the bell curve of top, middle and low performers.
At the end of October, Best Buy got a new CEO who has been through 27 years of review seasons at one company. Jason Bonfig joined Best Buy in 1999 as an inventory analyst. He has been rated, he has rated others, and he saw a path to growth there for 27 years. The Jefferies analysts said they liked the pick because Bonfig was "one step closer to the action." In July, months before he took the title, Best Buy had already moved five senior leaders into roles reporting to him.
One pattern: rated, but not developed
What I saw in practice was that managers were scared to write the feedback. They didn't exactly know how to give effective feedback, so a lot of what got written was very simple, things like "keep doing what you're doing." It filled the box, and it didn't serve the purpose of actually developing the employee.
Picture the same review two ways. In the first, the manager says "keep doing what you're doing," and the employee walks out with a good rating and no idea what comes next. In the second, the manager says, "Here's what you did well this year, and here is where I see you next," and the employee walks out feeling the company is invested in their growth. Same employee, same rating. The manager's feedback is what makes it or breaks it.
I would like to see AI encouraged in employee feedback, and that is exactly what I am building. Most managers can talk through what someone did well and what they need next far more easily than they can write it. Let them give the feedback verbally, and let AI capture it and write it.
Managers are already moving this way. A Nielsen survey for Monday.com, published October 22, found that 39% of 1,700 directors and senior managers already use AI to draft performance reviews.
And this is not only a big tech story. FICO is cutting about 15% of its workforce in an AI-driven restructuring. Comcast is calling its overhaul the largest operating and cost transformation in its history. IKEA went the other way: its chatbot Billie took the routine questions, and IKEA retrained roughly 8,500 call center workers to handle complex questions or work as design advisors, without blaming any cuts on AI. That is the version I would love to see Best Buy choose, and every insider CEO who has been through decades of review seasons.
One experiment for this week
If you manage people, pick your strongest performer and say their feedback out loud before you write a word. What did they do well this year, what do they need next, and where do you see their path going? Record it or talk it into an AI tool, then let it help you write it up. Read it back and ask yourself whether they would know where they are headed after reading it, or whether it just says "keep doing what you're doing."
If you are the one being reviewed, ask your boss two questions in your review conversation. "If my role opened up tomorrow, who would you name to replace me? And if your role opened, what would it take for my name to be on that list?"
Try one of these this week, then hit reply and tell me what you heard.
Why I am sending this
Most of the leaders I work with already have the results. What they often lack is a clear read on the story the room has already written about them. I built a tool for exactly that.
It is called The Read. It takes two minutes and it is free. You paste your role and your profile, and you get back the pattern the room reads in you right now, the one lever most likely costing you the next seat, and one small move to start closing the gap this week.
More next week.
Maddy
P.S. Have you ever been told "keep doing what you're doing" in a review? Hit reply and tell me what happened next. I read every reply.
Craft Your Confidence
Want the room read on your own career, live? Book a call with Maddy.
Get the next one in your inbox

The patterns nobody names, read by senior leaders every week. Free.